Chapter 09

Reviews and AI search

11 min readPart of Online Reviews: The Complete Guide

More customers now ask ChatGPT, Gemini, Claude, Perplexity or Google's AI Overviews which business to choose. When these assistants search the web, they answer from the pages they find, and review sites are among those pages. Part of how they choose is known, part isn't, and a business can act on both.

YouAI assistant

Who's a well-reviewed plumber near me who can come this week?

Answer, with web search

Cedar Ridge Plumbing is rated 4.8 on Google and is praised for clear quotes. Another option is a company rated 4.1 on Angi, where some customers mention slow callbacks. Sources: Google, Angi, the company websites.

  1. A rating it found. Quoted from a review site page, right or out of date.Review site
  2. A theme from reviews. What reviewers repeat becomes the summary.Reviews
  3. The pages it read. The sources you can check, and change.Citations
Illustrative example, not a real answer: an assistant's answer about plumbers, with what it took from review sites marked.

The short version

Be reviewed where AI assistants look

Key takeaways

  • Assistants answer from pages they find. With web search on, they read websites, listings and review sites, and show which ones they used.
  • Be reviewed where they look. Recent reviews on the sites assistants cite for your field give them accurate things to say about you.
  • Check, then fix the source. Ask the assistants what they say, and correct wrong facts on the pages they cite. Nobody can edit the answer itself.

The shift

Customers are asking AI who to choose

The change has been fast. In BrightLocal's 2026 survey of US adults, use of ChatGPT and other generative AI tools for local business recommendations rose from 6% the year before to 45%, making it the third most popular source of recommendations.6 The same survey found that 82% of consumers read AI-generated review summaries, and 23% would rely on those summaries alone to decide.6

The summaries aren't only in chat apps. Google Maps shows review summaries written with Gemini and lets people ask Maps questions about a place, grounded in Google's data about places and what the Maps community has contributed.2 Either way, the customer reads an assistant's version of your reviews before, or instead of, the reviews themselves.

Mechanics

How an assistant builds an answer about a business

The assistants differ, but the ones that search the web follow the same broad path, and their makers document the key steps.

  1. A question"Who's a well-reviewed dentist near me?" or "What do people say about this business?"
  2. A web searchThrough the assistant's own search crawler or a search index, such as Google's for AI Overviews.
  3. Pages it readsBusiness websites, listings such as Google Business Profiles, and review sites. This is the step you can influence.
  4. An answer with sourcesA written summary, often naming businesses and ratings, with links to the pages used.
A simplified path. The search and citation steps are described in Google's, OpenAI's, Anthropic's and Perplexity's own documentation.1345

What each company says about the search and source steps:

  • Google: there are no additional requirements to appear in AI Overviews or AI Mode, and no special optimizations needed; to be a supporting link, a page must be indexed and eligible to show in Google Search with a snippet.1
  • OpenAI: its OAI-SearchBot is used to surface websites in ChatGPT's search results, and sites that opt out of it won't be shown in ChatGPT search answers.3
  • Anthropic: Claude can search the web to give up-to-date, cited information, with direct citations so you can check the sources.4
  • Perplexity: it searches the internet, and each answer includes numbered citations linking to the original sources.5

None of them publishes how it decides which businesses to name. What's documented is that the answer comes from pages, and pages are something a business can see and improve.

Citations

Which sources assistants cite

Several marketing-software companies have measured which pages assistants cite. All three studies below are vendor studies with different methods, so read them as signals, not laws. They agree on the broad picture: business websites and listings make up most citations, and review sites are a real share.

Share of citations by type of source

Business websites
44%
Listings
42%
Reviews and social
8%
News, forums, other
6%
A listings-software company's study: 6.8 million citations from more than 1.6 million answers by Gemini, OpenAI and Perplexity, published October 9, 2025.7 Listings sites often carry ratings and reviews too.

A 2026 BrightLocal study of about 200,000 local searches on ChatGPT, Google AI Mode and AI Overviews found business websites behind 42% of citations, and Yelp behind 9.5%, cited for most of the businesses tracked.8 It also found the AI surfaces mentioned a tracked business less often than Google Maps did:

Searches in which a tracked business was mentioned

66%Google Maps
38%AI Overviews
33%ChatGPT
32%AI Mode
BrightLocal, a local-marketing software company: about 200,000 localized, non-branded searches for more than 1,300 business locations over 60 days, published September 16, 2026.8

Being named at all is harder than showing up in a map. A 2026 study by a marketing-software company, covering more than 350,000 locations of 2,751 multi-location brands, found ChatGPT recommended 1.2% of the brands' locations, against a 35.9% average appearance rate in Google's local 3-Pack, and the locations it recommended averaged 4.3 stars.9 Rating also shapes how an assistant describes you. When we asked four AI assistants what customers say about businesses we track on reviews.grades.com, they described businesses rated 4.8 stars or higher positively in 79% of answers, against 29% for businesses rated under 4.0. That is a correlation, not proof the rating causes it.10 Rating is one signal; how many reviews a business has, and on how many sites, are the obvious others. An assistant can only repeat what it finds, and a business with a few old reviews on one site gives it little to go on.

Review sites

Why being on the sites AI cites matters

When an assistant cites a review site, it quotes what's on that page. If your page there has a handful of reviews from three years ago, that's the rating and the story it repeats, even if your Google profile tells a better and more current one. The site that matters isn't always the one you watch: assistants also cite sites specific to a field, such as healthcare directories and Tripadvisor, as well as Google and Yelp.78

Three things follow:

  1. Find out which sites are cited for you. Ask the assistants the questions your customers ask, with web search on, and note the sources under each answer. They differ by assistant and by field. In our checks, assistants rarely linked to Google's own review pages: Yelp, the BBB and other third-party review sites were cited far more often.10 A review page with Smart sort offers customers those sites too, not only Google.
  2. Keep those pages current. Claim the profiles, correct the facts, and make sure recent customers can find them when you ask for reviews.
  3. Ask for reviews where they help most. A new review on a cited site with a thin or stale page changes what that page says far more than one more review on a site where you already have hundreds. How to ask for reviews covers the asking itself; the asking must stay the same for every customer.
Sample
GoogleCited in most AI answers about you; reviews current
Keep going
AngiCited by two assistants; 4.1 from 38 reviews, last one months ago
Most impact
HouzzNot cited yet; 27 reviews, last one 5 months ago
Some impact
Illustrative example for a sample plumbing company: review sites ordered by impact, where citations by AI assistants count alongside how thin or stale each page is.

Your website

Let the search crawlers in

Your own website is the source assistants cite most in the studies above, so make sure they can read it. Each company documents separate crawlers, and the one that feeds search answers is not the one used to train models. Blocking a training crawler is a separate choice from blocking a search crawler.

CompanyCrawler for search answersWhat the company saysCrawler for model training
OpenAIOAI-SearchBotSurfaces websites in ChatGPT's search results; sites opted out aren't shown in search answers.GPTBot
AnthropicClaude-SearchBotImproves search result quality for Claude users; Claude-User may visit a page when someone asks.ClaudeBot
PerplexityPerplexityBotSurfaces and links websites in Perplexity's results; not used to crawl content for AI foundation models.None listed
GoogleGoogle SearchAI Overviews and AI Mode link to pages that are indexed and eligible for a snippet.Not covered here
From each company's crawler and site-owner documentation, read November 2026.1345

Check your robots.txt, or ask whoever runs your site, before assuming you're visible. A rule written to keep out AI training can also keep you out of the answers if it names the search crawlers.

What to do

What a business can do

In order, then once a month

  1. 1
    Ask the assistants about yourself"What do customers say about [business]?" and "Is [business] well reviewed?", in ChatGPT, Gemini, Claude and Perplexity, with web search on.
    Start here
  2. 2
    Fix wrong facts at the sourceHours, services, prices and booking links on your website, your Google Business Profile and your listings.
    This week
  3. 3
    Check every rating they quoteAn out-of-date rating shows you which page they read. Update that profile.
    This week
  4. 4
    Ask for reviews on the cited sitesSame ask for every customer, with the cited sites that need reviews most placed first.
    Ongoing
  5. 5
    Keep reviews comingRecent reviews are what customers read, and what a fresh search finds.
    Ongoing
  6. 6
    Let search crawlers read your websiteAllow the search crawlers in robots.txt, even if you block training.
    Once
  7. 7
    Ask again next monthNote what changed in the answers and the sources.
    Monthly
A working routine, not a guarantee. Google says AI Overviews need no special optimization beyond being a page Google can index and show.1

What doesn't work: buying or faking reviews (the FTC's rule bans fake reviews and paying for positive ones), stuffing pages with keywords written for machines, or paying anyone who promises a guaranteed spot in an AI answer. Nobody can promise that.

Limits

What nobody knows yet

This is a young field, and honest advice includes its limits.

The selection logic is private. No assistant publishes how it weighs ratings, review counts or sources when it names a business.

Answers vary. Ask the same question twice and you can get different businesses. BrightLocal measured 91% to 96% agreement between repeated runs on the AI surfaces, against about 99% for Google Maps.8

The studies are early. The research on citations comes from companies that sell marketing software, uses different methods, and covers different assistants and periods. It can change as the assistants do.

So treat any single number, including the ones on this page, as a snapshot. The durable advice is the same as for human readers: be accurate, be current, and be reviewed where people look.

Grades.com

See what AI tells your customers

Grades.com runs the checks in this chapter for you and turns them into the next review to ask for.

  • AI Reputation: asks ChatGPT, Perplexity, Gemini and Claude what a customer would ask about you, with web search on, and shows every answer, the ratings they quote, whether each rating is current, and the pages they cite.
  • Smart sort: the review sites on your review page, ordered by impact, where a site AI assistants cite for you counts for up to 35 of 100 points, beside how thin or stale your page there is.
  • Reviews MCP: connect Claude or ChatGPT to your account and ask what changed in the AI answers since last month.

14-day free trial of Pro, no card needed.

Frequently asked questions

Can I change what ChatGPT says about my business?

Not directly. Nobody can edit an assistant's answer. When an assistant searches the web, it writes from the pages it finds, so the way to change the answer is to change those pages: your website, your listings and your profiles on the review sites it cites.

Do I need to do anything special to appear in Google's AI Overviews?

Google says no. Its guidance for site owners says there are no additional requirements to appear in AI Overviews or AI Mode and no special optimizations needed; a page must be indexed and eligible to show in Google Search with a snippet.

Should I block AI crawlers on my website?

Decide crawler by crawler. OpenAI, Anthropic and Perplexity each document a crawler for search answers and, separately, crawlers for other purposes such as model training. OpenAI says sites that opt out of OAI-SearchBot won't be shown in ChatGPT search answers, so blocking a search crawler can keep your own website out of the answers.

Which review sites do AI assistants cite?

It depends on the assistant, the question and the field. Published studies, all by marketing-software companies, find that business websites and listings such as Google Business Profiles make up most citations, with review sites such as Yelp a smaller but real share. The way to know for your business is to ask the assistants and look at what they cite.

Is there a way to guarantee an AI assistant recommends my business?

No. The assistants don't publish how they choose businesses, and their answers vary from one run to the next. What you can do is make sure the pages they read are accurate and current, and that customers have reviewed you on the sites they cite.

Notes

Sources

  1. Google Search Central, "AI features and your website", read November 2026. Google
  2. Google, "New in Maps: Inspiration curated with Gemini, enhanced navigation and more", The Keyword, October 31, 2024. Google
  3. OpenAI, "Overview of OpenAI Crawlers", read November 2026. OpenAI
  4. Anthropic, "Claude can now search the web", March 20, 2025; Claude Help Center, "Does Anthropic crawl data from the web, and how can site owners block the crawler?", read November 2026. Web search · Crawlers
  5. Perplexity Help Center, "How does Perplexity work?", and Perplexity docs, "Perplexity Crawlers", read November 2026. Help Center · Crawlers
  6. BrightLocal consumer review survey, 2026 (published February 11, 2026): 1,002 US adults on a representative SurveyMonkey panel. Survey
  7. "AI Doesn't Rank, It Cites. And 86% of Its Sources Are Brand-Managed", blog of a listings-software company, October 9, 2025. Vendor study: 6.8 million citations from more than 1.6 million answers by Gemini, OpenAI and Perplexity; collection period not stated. Study
  8. BrightLocal, local AI visibility study, September 16, 2026. Vendor study: about 200,000 non-branded localized searches on ChatGPT, Google AI Mode and AI Overviews for more than 1,300 locations over 60 days; the page gives slightly different totals in places. BrightLocal
  9. 2026 Local Visibility Index, a marketing-software company's study, January 28, 2026. Vendor study: more than 350,000 locations of 2,751 multi-location brands. Study
  10. Grades.com directory data: 17,005 answers from ChatGPT, Perplexity, Gemini and Claude about 4,392 businesses tracked on reviews.grades.com (Grades.com customers excluded), October 23 to November 17, 2026, counted November 17, 2026. Each prompt named the business and asked what customers say about it on Google, Yelp and other review sites, so those two are overstated in what the answers name; tone classified by Grades.com's model. Correlation only.