Chapter 04

Keep every review

8 min readPart of Online Reviews: The Complete Guide

Reviews stop showing all the time, including good ones and ones that are years old, and the sites rarely say why. The only complete record of your reviews is the one you keep yourself.

Review history Sample

  1. ★★★★★Posted March 2023. On Google until November 7, 2026, then it stopped showing.Kept
  2. ★★★★★Edited last week. It was two stars before; the site now shows the edit date only.Both versions
  3. ★★★★★Posted yesterday. Still live on Facebook.Live
A sample review history: a five-star review from 2023 that stopped showing on Google and is kept, an edited review with both versions kept, and a new review that is still live.

The short version

Keep your own copy of every review

Key takeaways

  • Reviews can disappear at any time, including five-star reviews and ones that are years old, and the sites do not say why.
  • Filters, policy sweeps, profile changes and reviewers themselves all take reviews down, and from the outside they look the same.
  • Keep your own copy of every review, with its date, rating, text and your reply: it is your proof, your history and the record that shows patterns.

Why it happens

Why reviews stop showing

A review on Google, Yelp or Facebook is not yours. It belongs to the person who wrote it and lives on a site that can hide it, filter it or delete it whenever its rules say so. Most of the time nobody tells you. You notice a count that went down, or a customer mentions a review you can no longer find.

The sites' own help pages name the main causes. None of them explains a single review, so when one goes you rarely learn which cause it was.

  • FiltersAutomated checks screen reviews for spam and policy problems, and they keep running after a review is posted. Google says reviews are removed for violations like spam or inappropriate content.1 Yelp's recommendation software filters reviews it considers potentially unreliable, including ones that may have been solicited.4 Trustpilot runs reviews flagged as not genuine through its detection software and removes the ones that look suspicious.6
  • Policy sweepsSites change their rules and apply them to whole groups at once. Google can temporarily switch off reviews for certain profiles or categories, and it removed and disabled reviews for profiles categorized as schools for students aged 6 to 18.1
  • Profile changesMerging two profiles, or getting a suspended one reinstated, moves reviews around. Google warns that reviews might be removed after a profile is reinstated.1
  • ReviewersThe author can edit or delete a review at any time, and on Google an edited review shows the date of the last edit as its post date.2 Closing a Google Account deletes the data and content in it.3 On Facebook, a recommendation you saw before may have been removed, or its author may have changed who can see it.5
  • ReportsSomeone reported the review and the site agreed it broke a rule. The report can come from you, a competitor or any customer: on Facebook, for one, anyone who sees a recommendation can report it.5
Five ways a review stops showing, from the sites' own help pages, read November 2026.

From the outside these causes look identical: the review was there yesterday and today it is not. Even a large set of data cannot tell a filter from a successful report or a reviewer who deleted their own words, which is why this guide says a review "stopped showing" rather than claiming to know who took it down.

Not just the bad ones

Good reviews and old reviews disappear too

It is tempting to think only fake or nasty reviews go. They do go, but the filters and sweeps do not check whether a review was kind to you. A happy customer's five-star review can be caught by the same check as a competitor's one-star attack, especially when the reviewer rarely posts, posted from a new account, or was asked for the review in a way the site's software reads as solicited.4

Age is no protection either. Reviews can disappear at any time, including ones that are years old, and Google does not say why. When Google takes a review down, it usually happens within days or weeks of posting, not months. The exceptions are the ones nobody notices: a review from three years ago that quietly drops off, with no notice to you.

On the BBB that is routine: of the BBB reviews that stopped showing at the businesses we track on reviews.grades.com in November 2026, 88% were 36 to 37 months old, so BBB reviews stop showing once they are about three years old.7 The BBB publishes a three-year window for complaints on its profiles, though not for reviews.8

A review that stops showing for a policy reason is usually gone for good: Google says reviews removed for policy violations won't be restored.1

Your own record

Four reasons to keep your own copy

The site's copy of a review is the only one most businesses have, and it can change or go without notice. A copy of your own, taken when the review arrives, is worth having for four reasons.

  1. ProofWhen you report a review, appeal a decision, answer a dispute or talk to a lawyer, you need the exact words, the rating and the date as they were posted. A screenshot taken after the reviewer edited it shows the wrong review.
  2. HistoryYour rating over time, the reviews from your first year and the replies you wrote are part of how you got here. When a site drops reviews, its count and average change, and only your own record shows what you actually earned.
  3. Marketing useThe kindest words customers wrote about you are worth quoting. Your archive tells you which reviews are still live on their site, so the ones you quote can be checked by anyone who looks.
  4. PatternsA wave of reviews disappearing in one week, one reviewer editing a rating down after every visit, a complaint that keeps coming back: patterns only show when every review, and every version of it, sits in one place.

Do it yourself

How to keep a review archive by hand

You do not need software to start. A shared spreadsheet and a folder of screenshots work for a business with a few reviews a month on one or two sites.

  1. Capture every review the day it arrives, on every site, not only the bad ones. Save a full-page screenshot that shows the reviewer's name, the stars, the date and the text.
  2. Log it in one sheet: site, date, reviewer name as posted, rating, the full text, a link to the review and your reply with its date.
  3. Check the sites once a month against the sheet. Mark any review you can no longer find with the date you noticed, and any review whose rating or words changed, keeping the old version in its own row.
  4. Keep the reports you file in the same sheet: the date, the rule you named and what the site decided.
  5. Store it where it lasts: a company account with access for more than one person, not a phone or a personal inbox.

The weak spot of a hand-made archive is the gap between captures. A review that was edited the day after it was posted, or that stopped showing between two monthly checks, may never make it into the sheet. The more sites and locations you have, the bigger that gap gets.

When it happens

What to do when a review disappears

Check it really went. Look while signed out and on another device; a review can be hidden from one view and not another, and on Facebook its author may only have changed who can see it.5

Note the date and keep your copy. If several reviews went in the same week, write that down too: a cluster points at a filter, a sweep or a profile change rather than at single reviewers.

Ask the site only when it looks like a mistake. On Google, Business Profile support can look at missing reviews; send the screenshot of the review and the date it went.1 Do not expect an explanation of a single review.

Never post it again or pay for it back. Reposting a customer's review under another name is a fake review, and offering a customer something to post again is an incentive the sites and the FTC ban. Keep asking every customer for reviews the same way you always do; how to ask for reviews has wording that follows each site's rules.

Watch your reply. When a review goes, your public reply goes with it. Keep the reply in your archive as well: it is part of your record of how you handle customers.

Grades.com

Keep every review, even the ones a site drops

Review Monitoring brings every review into one inbox, and its Review Archive keeps a copy of each one Grades.com collects.

  • Every review, every site, one list: Google, Facebook, Tripadvisor and your other sites, within hours of posting.
  • A review that leaves its site stays in your archive with its rating, text, date and your reply, marked with the day it stopped showing.
  • Edited reviews keep every earlier version, and one filter lists every review that left its site.

Starter brings in your Google reviews; Pro and Premium bring in every site you connect. The archive is private to you and starts with what each site still shows when you connect.

14-day free trial of Pro, no card needed.

Frequently asked questions

Why did a good review disappear from my Google profile?

Google does not explain single reviews. The reasons it lists for missing reviews include its policy and spam checks, merged or reinstated profiles and reviews switched off for some profiles or categories. The reviewer may also have edited or deleted the review, or closed their account.

Can I get a review back once it stops showing?

Rarely. Google says reviews removed for policy violations won't be restored. If you think a review went by mistake, contact Business Profile support with a screenshot of the review and the date it went. Never post it again yourself or ask anyone to post it for you.

Can I quote a review that a site no longer shows?

Better not. You usually can't tell why it went, and if the site took it down as fake, quoting it could mislead. Keep it as a record and quote reviews that are still live.

Does Grades.com keep reviews from before I connect a site?

It keeps every review it collects. The first sync brings in what each site still shows, so a review that left a site before you connected cannot be recovered. That is the reason to start an archive early.

Can anyone else see my Review Archive?

No. The archive is private to you, on every plan. Reviews that left their site never appear on your public review page, your widgets or the Grades.com directory.

Notes

Sources

  1. Google Business Profile Help, "About missing or delayed reviews", read November 17, 2026. Missing or delayed reviews
  2. Google Maps Help, "Add, edit, or delete Google Maps reviews and ratings", read November 17, 2026. Edit or delete reviews
  3. Google Account Help, "Delete your Google Account", read November 17, 2026. Delete your Google Account
  4. Yelp Support, "What is Yelp's recommendation software?", read November 17, 2026. Recommendation software
  5. Facebook Help Center, "Report a recommendation on a Facebook Page", read November 17, 2026. Report a recommendation
  6. Trustpilot, "Guidelines for businesses" (flagging and what happens to flagged reviews), read November 17, 2026. Guidelines for businesses
  7. Grades.com directory data: public BBB reviews of 618 businesses tracked on reviews.grades.com (Grades.com customers excluded): 608 of 47,178 BBB reviews stopped showing between November 2 and 17, 2026, counted November 17, 2026. Correlation only.
  8. BBB, "How BBB Complaints Are Handled": complaints appear on BBB Business Profiles for three years from the date filed. BBB publishes no display period for customer reviews. Read November 17, 2026. BBB