Online Reviews: The Complete Guide
Turn your reviews into new customers
Ten short chapters, each with real data and a tool to act on it.
Chapter 01 How online reviews work
See every review in one place
Reviews live on many sites, each with its own rules, so you need one place that sees all of them.
Key point
Every review site sets its own rules for what it shows, how it filters reviews and how a business can reply, and the rules change without notice.
Chapter 02 Getting more reviews
Reach the rating you want
Your rating moves only as fast as new reviews arrive, so asking every customer, every time, is the whole job.
What the data shows
The typical business we track gets about 9 new Google reviews a month, and the pace varies tenfold by industry: car dealers get about 27, dentists about 16, lawyers about 6. About 1 in 12 had no new Google review in the past 90 days. Source: public Google reviews of 3,087 businesses tracked on reviews.grades.com (Grades.com customers excluded), posted in the 12 months to November 17, 2026, counted November 17, 2026; median per business; correlation only.
Star rating calculator
Rounds the way Google shows ratings. For an exact answer by star level, use the Google review calculator.
To reach your target
-
Enter your rating and review count.
Chapter 03 Spread reviews across sites
Get reviewed where customers look
Customers and AI assistants check more than one site, so where a new review lands matters as much as getting it.
What the data shows
For 88% of the businesses we track, 90% or more of their known reviews are on Google. Car dealers are the exception, with real weight on Cars.com and DealerRater. One link that offers more than one site spreads reviews out. Source: known review counts per site for 4,431 businesses tracked on reviews.grades.com (Grades.com customers excluded), counted November 17, 2026, on the sites Grades.com tracks; correlation only.
Source mix checker
Your source mix
-
Enter how many reviews you have on each site.
Chapter 04 Keep every review
Never lose a review you earned
Reviews stop showing without warning, even good and old ones, so the only copy you can count on is your own.
What the data shows
Reviews can disappear at any time, and old ones go quietly: of the BBB reviews that stopped showing at the businesses we track in November 2026, 88% were 36 to 37 months old, so BBB reviews disappear at about 3 years. Source: public BBB reviews of 618 businesses tracked on reviews.grades.com (Grades.com customers excluded), 608 of 47,178 stopped showing November 2 to 17, 2026; correlation only.
Reviews at risk
We have not published a rate yet. Try your own.
Reviews that may stop showing
-a year
-over three years
Review Archive keeps each one with its rating, text, date and your reply.
Chapter 05 Responding to reviews
Win the next customer with every reply
Every reply is read by the next customer, so every review deserves a fast, careful answer.
What the data shows
About 3 in 10 one- and two-star Google reviews at the businesses we track never got a reply from the business. For 5-star reviews it was about 1 in 4. Source: public Google reviews of 4,354 businesses tracked on reviews.grades.com (Grades.com customers excluded): 26,240 one- and two-star reviews posted in the 12 months to November 17, 2026, counted November 17, 2026; correlation only.
Chapter 06 Fake and unfair reviews
Report reviews that break the rules
A review that breaks a site's rules can be reported, and the report works best with the rule and the proof in hand.
Key point
When Google stops showing a review, it usually happens within days or weeks of posting, not months.
Chapter 07 Putting reviews to work
Put reviews where customers decide
A review works harder on your website and in your feeds than it does on a review site alone.
Key point
Reviews on your own website work best when they are recent and sit next to your true overall rating, so nobody has to wonder what was left out.
Chapter 08 Learning from reviews
Find out what to fix next
Reviews are free customer research, as long as you read them together instead of one at a time.
Key point
The same complaint repeated across reviews says more about what to fix than any single rating does.
Chapter 09 Reviews and AI search
Know what AI tells your customers
AI assistants now answer "who should I choose?" from your reviews, so you need to see what they say about you.
What the data shows
Asked what customers say about a business, four AI assistants described businesses rated 4.8 stars or higher positively in 79% of answers, against 29% for those under 4.0. They rarely linked Google's own review pages: Yelp, the BBB and other third-party review sites were cited far more often. Source: 17,005 answers from ChatGPT, Perplexity, Gemini and Claude about 4,392 businesses tracked on reviews.grades.com (Grades.com customers excluded), October 23 to November 17, 2026; the prompt named Google and Yelp; correlation only.
Chapter 10 The rules
Ask every customer the same way
The rules on reviews carry real penalties, so the safest process is one where every customer gets the same ask.
Key point
The FTC rule on consumer reviews applies to every business that asks for, shows or answers reviews, and its penalties are counted per violation.
Glossary
Review terms in plain English
- Review gating
- Asking customers how they feel first and sending only the happy ones to a review site. The FTC rule on consumer reviews and the review sites' own policies ban it. See chapter 10.
- Review velocity
- How many new reviews you get in a given period, such as a month. A steady pace keeps your rating current. See chapter 02.
- Review page
- One link or QR code that lists your review sites, so each customer picks the site they already use. See chapter 03.
- Smart sort
- A Grades.com setting that orders the sites on your review page by impact: where one more review helps most, including the sites AI assistants cite. See chapter 03.
- Source mix
- How your reviews are spread across review sites. Check yours with the source mix checker.
- Review archive
- A private copy of every review collected, kept even after a site stops showing it. See chapter 04.
- Review dispute
- A report to a review site that a review breaks the site's rules, with the rule and the proof. The site decides. See chapter 06.
- Review widget
- A block of your reviews on your own website, kept current from your review sites. See chapter 07.
- AI citation
- A page or review site an AI assistant names as a source in its answer. See chapter 09.
- Response rate
- The share of your reviews you have replied to. See chapter 05.
Every chapter, in one dashboard
14-day free trial of Pro, no card needed.




BBB